Pages

Tuesday, October 22, 2024

A Rotten Apple - Perfection - William Carlos Williams

Rosa 'Bathsheba' 22 October 2024

 

   Perfection – William Carlos Williams

               O lovely apple!

beautifully and completely

                 rotten

hardly a contour marred--

                 perhaps a little

shrivelled at the top but that

                 aside perfect

in every detail! O lovely

                 apple! what a

deep and suffusing brown

                 mantles that

unspoiled surface! No one

                 has moved you

since I placed you on the porch

                 rail a month ago

to ripen.

                 No one. No one!

 

When my wife urged me forcefully that we were going to attend a meeting of the Vancouver Rose Society at the Floral Hall of Van Dusen, sometime around 1990, I found myself sitting in an uncomfortable chair watching 100 bad projected close-up slides of roses. But Rosemary prevailed and I ended up being as interested as she in growing them.

To this day I have never participated in the annual rose show where they have rules(in my opinion onerous of the Victorian kind)  on how to display roses in the rose show.

Recently they have started and awfully popular where we bring (and I participate) our roses to the meetings without any instructions on how to display them.

Today when I saw this English Rose, Rosa ‘Bathsheba’ I noticed that the bloom was not central but to one side. This rose would not have been accepted in that annual rose show. 

It is getting cold and rainy so roses are on their last legs. To me this rose was beautiful. I scanned it, carefull to lean it so you can see the off-centre centre. I thought that in its own way it is perfect. I found William Carlos Williams’s poem about rotten apples fit the bill.